General Headquarters,
Home Forces,
Horse Guards,
London, S.W.
29th May, 1916.
My Lord,—
I have the honour to forward herewith a Report which I have received
from the General Officer Commanding-in-chief, Irish Command, relating
to the recent outbreak in Dublin and the measures taken for its
suppression.
2. It will be observed that the rebellion broke out in Dublin
at 12.15 p.m. on April 24th, and that by 5.20 p.m. on the same
afternoon a considerable force from the Curragh had arrived in
Dublin to reinforce the garrison, and other troops were on their
way from Athlone, Belfast, and Templemore. The celerity with which
these reinforcements became available says much for the arrangements
which had been made to meet such a contingency.
3. I was informed of the outbreak by wire on the afternoon of
the 24th ult., and the 59th Division at St. Albans was at once
put under orders to proceed to Ireland, and arrangements were
put in train for their transport. After seeing General Friend
I gave orders for the movement of two brigades to commence as
soon as their transport could be arranged. I am aware that in
doing so I was acting beyond the powers which were delegated to
me, but I considered the situation to be so critical that it was
necessary to act at once without reference to the Army Council.
4. On the morning of the 28th April General Sir John Maxwell,
K.C.B., .K.C.M.G., C.V.O., D.S.O., arrived in Ireland to assume
command.
5. I beg to bring to your notice the assistance afforded to me
by the Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty, who met every request
made to them for men, guns and transport with the greatest promptitude,
and whose action enabled me to reinforce and maintain the garrisons
in the South and West of Ireland without unduly drawing upon the
troops which it was desirable to retain in England.
I have the honour to be,
Your Lordship's most obedient Servant,
FRENCH,
Field-Marshal,
Commanding-in-Chief, Home Forces.
From the General Officer, Commanding-in-Chief, The Forces in Ireland.
To the Field-Marshal, Commanding-in-Chief, The Home Forces.
Headquarters,
Irish Command, Dublin,
25th May, 1916.
My Lord,—
I have the honour to report the operations of the Forces now under
my command from Monday, 24th April, when the rising in Dublin
began.
(1) On Easter Monday, 24th April, at 12.15 p.m., a telephone message
was received from the Dublin Metropolian Police saying that Dublin
Castle was being attacked by armed Sinn Feiners. This was immediately
confirmed by the Dublin Garrison Adjutant, who reported that,
in the absence of Colonel Kennard, the Garrison Commander, who
had left his office shortly before, and was prevented by the rebels
from returning, he had ordered all available troops from Portobello,
Richmond and Royal Barracks to proceed to the Castle, and the
6th Reserve Cavalry Regiment towards Sackville Street.
The fighting strengths of the troops available in Dublin at this
moment were: —
6th Reserve Cavalry Regiment, 35 officers, 851 other ranks.
3rd Royal Irish Regiment, 18 officers, 385 other ranks.
10th Royal Dublin Fusiliers, 37 officers, 430 other ranks.
3rd Royal Irish Rifles, 21 officers, 650 other ranks.
Of these troops, an inlying picquet of 400 men, which for some
days past had been held in readiness, proceeded at once, and the
remainder followed shortly afterwards. At 12.30 p.m. a telephone
message was sent to General Officer Commanding, Curragh, to mobilize
the mobile column, which had been arranged for to meet any emergency,
and to despatch it dismounted to Dublin by trains which were being
sent from Kingsbridge. This column, under the command of Colonel
Portal, consisted of 1,600 officers and other ranks from the 3rd
Reserve Cavalry Brigade. Almost immediately after the despatch
of this message telephonic communication in Dublin became very
interrupted, and from various sources it was reported that the
Sinn Feiners had seized the General Post Office in Sackville Street,
the Magazine in Phoenix Park, The Four Courts, Jacobs' Biscuit
Factory, and had occupied many buildings in various parts of the
City.
As the occupation of the General Post Office by the Sinn Feiners
denied the use of the telegraph, a message reporting the situation
in Dublin was sent at 1.10 p.m. to the Naval Centre at Kingstown,
asking that the information of the rising might be transmitted
by wireless through the Admiralty to you. This was done.
(2) The first objectives undertaken by the troops were to recover
possession of the Magazine in Phoenix Park, where the rebels had
set fire to a quantity of ammunition, to relieve the Castle, and
to strengthen the guards on Vice-Regal Lodge and other points
of importance. The Magazine was quickly re-occupied, but the troops
moving on the Castle were held up by the rebels who had occupied
surrounding houses, and had barricaded the streets with carts
and other material. Between 1.40 p.m. and 2.0 p.m., 50 men of
3rd Royal Irish Rifles, and 130 men of the 10th Royal Dublin Fusiliers
reached the Castle by the Ship Street entrance. At 4.45 p.m. the
first train from the Curragh arrived at Kingsbridge station, and
by 5.20 p.m. the whole Cavalry Column, 1,600 strong, under the
command of Colonel Portal, had arrived, one train being sent on
from Kingsbridge to North Wall by the loop line to reinforce the
guard over the docks.
(3) During the day the following troops were ordered to Dublin
: —
(a) A battery of four 18-pounders R.F.A., from the Reserve Artillery
Brigade at Athlone.
(6) The 4th Dublin Fusiliers from Templemore.
(c) A composite battalion from Belfast.
(d) An additional 1,000 men from the Curragh. This message being
sent by one of the troop trains returning to the Curragh. During
the afternoon and evening small parties of troops were engaged
with the rebels. The 3rd Royal Irish Regiment on their way to
the Castle were held up by the rebels in the South Dublin Union,
which they attacked and partially occupied; a detachment of 2
officers and 50 men from the 6th Reserve Cavalry Regiment which
was convoying some ammunition from North Wall, was surrounded
in Charles Street, but succeeded in parking their convoy and defended
this with great gallantry for 3 1/2 days, when they were relieved
; during this defence the officer in command was killed and the
remaining officer wounded.
The rebels in St. Stephen's Green were attacked, and picquets
with machine guns were established in the United Service Club
and the Shelbourne Hotel with a view to dominating the square
and its exits. At 9.35 p.m. Colonel Kennard, Officer Commanding
Troops, Dublin, reached the Castle with another party of 86 men
of the 3rd Royal Irish Regiment.
The defence of the Docks at North Wall was undertaken by Major
H. F. Somerville, commanding a detachment from the School of Musketry,
Dollymount, reinforced by 330 officers and men of the 9th Reserve
Cavalry Regiment. The occupation of the Customs House, which dominated
Liberty Hall, was carried out at night, and was of great assistance
in later operations against Liberty Hall.
(4) The situation at midnight was that we held the Magazine, Phoenix
Park, the Castle and the Ship Street entrance to it, the Royal
Hospital, all Barracks, the Kingsbridge, Amiens Street, and North
Wall railway stations, the Dublin telephone exchange in Crown
Alley, the Electric Power Station atPigeon.House Fort, Trinity
College, Mountjoy Prison, and Kingstown Harbour. The Sinn Feiners
held Sackville Street and blocks of buildings on each side of
this, including Liberty Hall, with their headquarters at the General
Post Office, the Four Courts, Jacobs' biscuit factory, South Dublin
Union, St. Stephen's Green, all the approaches to the Castle except
the Ship Street entrance, and many houses all over the city, especially
about Balls Bridge and Beggar's Bush.
(5) The facility with which the Sinn Feiners were able to seize
so many important points throughout the city was, in my opinion,
due to the fact that armed bodies of civilians have been continually
allowed to parade in and march through the streets of Dublin and
throughout the country without interference. The result was that
the movement of large forces of armed civilians, particularly
on a holiday such as Easter Monday, passed, if not unnoticed,
unchecked, and no opposition could be offered to them at the moment
when they decided to act. Further, the Dublin police, being unarmed
and powerless to deal with these armed rebels, were withdrawn
from the areas occupied by them.
(6) At the time of the rising Major-General Friend, then commanding
the troops in Ireland, was on short leave in England, and when
visiting your headquarters at the Horse Guards on that day heard
the serious news from Dublin. He returned that night, and arrived
in Dublin early on the morning of the 25th April. He has informed
me that at a conference with you it was decided to despatch at
once two infantry brigades of the 59th Division from England to
Ireland, and that the remaining infantry brigade and artillery
of this Division were to be held in readiness to follow if required.
(7) On April 25th, Brigadier-General W. H. M. Lowe, Commanding
the Reserve Cavalry Brigade at the Curragh, arrived at Kingsbridge
station at 3.45 a.m. with the leading troops from the 25th (Irish)
Reserve Infantry Brigade, and assumed command of the forces in
the Dublin area, which were roughly 2,300 men of the Dublin garrison,
the Curragh Mobile Column of 1,500 dismounted cavalrymen, and
840 men of the 25th Irish Reserve Infantry Brigade.
(8) In order to relieve and get communication with the Castle,
Colonel Portal, Commanding the Curragh Mobile Column, was ordered
to establish a line of posts from Kingsbridge station to Trinity
College via the Castle. This was completed by 12 noon, 25th April,
and with very little loss. It divided the rebel forces into two,
gave a safe line of advance for troops extending operations to
the north or south, and permitted communication by despatch rider
with some of the Commands. The only means of communication previous
to this had been by telephone, which was unquestionably being
tapped. The Dublin University O.T.C., under Captain E. H. Alton,
and subsequently Major
G. A. Harris, held the College buildings until the troops arrived.
The holding of these buildings separated the rebel centre round
the General Post Office from that round St. Stephen's Green; it
established a valuable base for the collection of. reinforcements
as they arrived, and prevented the rebels from entering the Bank
of Ireland, which is directly opposite to and commanded by the
College buildings.
(9) During the day the 4th Royal Dublin Fusiliers from Templemore,
a composite Ulster battalion from Belfast, and a battery of four
18-pounder guns from the Reserve Artillery Brigade at Athlone
arrived, and this allowed a cordon to be established round the
northern part of the city from Parkgate, along the North Circular
Road to North Wall. Broadstone Railway Station was cleared of
rebels, and a barricade near Phibsborough was destroyed by artillery
fire. As a heavy fire was being kept up on the Castle from the
rebels located in the-Corporation buildings, Daily Express offices
and several houses opposite the City Hall, it was decided to attack
these buildings. The assault on the Daily Express office was successfully
carried out under very heavy fire by a detachment of the 5th Royal
Dublin Fusiliers under 2nd Lieut. F. O'Neill. The main forces
of the rebels now having been located in and around Sackville
Street, the Four Courts and adjoining buildings, it was decided
to try to enclose that area north of the Liffey by a cordon of
troops so as to localise as far as possible the efforts of the
rebels.
(10) Towards evening the 178th Infantry Brigade began to arrive
at Kingstown, and in accordance with orders received the brigade
left Kingstown by road in two columns. The left column, consisting
of the 5th and 6th Battalions, Sherwood Foresters, by the Stillorgan-Donnybrook
road and South Circular road to the Royal. Hospital, where it
arrived without opposition. The right column, consisting of the
7th and 8th Battalions, Sherwood Foresters, by the main tram route
through Ballsbridge, and directed on Merrion Square and Trinity
College. This column, with 7th Battalion leading, was held up
at the northern corner of Haddington Road and Northumberland Avenue,
which was strongly held by rebels; but with the assistance of
bombing parties organized and led by Captain Jeffares, of the
Bombing School at Elm Park, the rebels were driven back. At 3.25
p.m. the 7th. Battalion, Sherwood Foresters, met great opposition
from the rebels holding the schools and other houses on the north
side of the road close to the bridge at Lower Mount Street, and
two officers; one of whom was the Adjutant, Captain Dietrichsen,
were killed and seven wounded, including Lieutenant-Colonel Fane,
who, though wounded, remained in action. At about 5.30p.m. orders
were received that the advance to Trinity College was to be pushed
forward at all costs, and therefore at about 8 p.m., after careful
arrangements, the whole column, accompanied by bombing parties,
attacked the schools and houses where the chief opposition lay,
the battalions charging in successive waves carried all before
them, but, I regret to say, suffered severe casualties in doing
so. Four officers were killed, 14 wounded, and of otlher ranks
216 were killed and wounded. The steadiness shown by these two
battalions is deserving of special mention, as I understand the
majority of the men have less than three months' service. In view
of the opposition met with, it was not considered advisable to
push on to Trinity College that night, so at 11 p.m. the 5th South
Staffordshire Regiment, from the 176th Infantry Brigade, reinforced
this column, and by occupying the positions gained allowed the
two battalions Sherwood Foresters to be concentrated at Ballsbridge.
In connection with this fighting at Mount Street Bridge, where
our heaviest casualties occurred, I should like to mention the
gallant assistance given by a number of medical men, ladies, nurses
and women servants, who at great risk brought in and tended to
the wounded, continuing their efforts even when deliberately fired
at by the rebels.
(11) Meanwhile severe fighting had taken place in the Sackville
Street quarter. At 8a.m. Liberty Hall, the former headquarters
of the Sinn Feiners, was attacked by field guns from the south
bank of the River Liffey, and by a gun from the patrol ship Helga,
with the result that considerable progress was made. During the
night of 26th/27th April several fires broke out in this quarter
and threatened to become dangerous, as the fire brigade could
not get to work owing to their being fired upon by the rebels.
Throughout the day further troops of the
176th Brigade arrived in the Dublin area.
(12) On 27th April the 5th Leinsters, 2/6th Sherwood Foresters,
3rd Royal Irish Regiment, The Ulster composite battalion, under
the command of Colonel Portal, began and completed by 5 p.m. the
forming of a cordon round the rebels in the Sackville Street area,
which operation was carried out with small loss. About 12.45 p.m.
Linen Hall barracks, which were occupied by the Army Pay Office,
were reported to have been set on fire by the rebels and were
destroyed. By night-fall the 177th Infantry Brigade had arrived
at Kingstown, where it remained for the night.
(13) At 2 a.m. on the 28th April, I arrived at North Wall and
found many buildings in Sackville Street burning fiercely, illuminating
the whole city, and a fusilade of rifle fire going on in several
quarters of the city. Accompanied by several Staff Officers who
had come with me, I proceeded to the Royal Hospital. After a conference
with Major-General Friend and Brigadier-General Lowe, I instructed
the latter to close in on Sackville Street from East and West,
and to carry out a house-to-house search in areas gained. I was
able to place the 2/4th Lincolns at his disposal for the purpose
of forming a cordon along the Grand Canal, so enclosing the southern
part of the city and forming a complete cordon round Dublin. During
the afternoon the 2/5th and 2/6th South Staffords arrived at Trinity
College, and this additional force allowed me to begin the task
of placing a cordon round the Four Courts area in the same way
as the Sackville Street area, which had already been so successfully
isolated. During the evening the detachment of the 6th Reserve
Cavalry Regiment, which had been escorting ammunition and rifles
from North Wall, and had been held up in Charles Street, was relieved
by armoured motor lorries, which had been roughly armoured with
boiler plates by the Inchicore Railway works and placed at my
disposal by Messrs. Guinness.
Throughout the night the process of driving out the rebels in
and round Sackville Street continued, though these operations
were greatly hampered by the fires in this area and by the fact
that some of the burning houses contained rebel stores of explosives
which every now and again blew up. In other quarters of the city
the troops had a trying time dealing with the numerous snipers,
who became very troublesome during the hours of darkness.
(14) Owing to the considerable opposition at barricades, especially
in North King Street, it was not until 9 a.m. on the 29th April
that the
Four Courts area was completely surrounded. Throughout the morning
the squeezing out of the surrounded areas was vigorously proceeded
with, the infantry being greatly assisted by a battery of Field
Artillery commanded by Major Hill, who used his guns against the
buildings held by the rebels with such good effect that a Red
Cross Nurse brought in a message from the Rebel leader, P. H.
Pearse, asking for terms. A reply was sent that only unconditional
surrender would be accepted. At 2 p.m. Pearse surrendered himself
unconditionally, and was brought before me, when he wrote and
signed notices ordering the various "Commandos" to surrender
unconditionally. During the evening the greater part of the rebels
in the Sackville Street and Four Courts area surrendered.
(15) Early on the 30th April two Franciscan monks informed me
that the Rebel leader Macdonagh, declining to accept Pearse's
orders, wished to negotiate. He was informed that only unconditional
surrender would be accepted, and at 3 p.m., when all preparation
for an attack on Jacobs' Biscuit Factory, which he held, had been
made, Macdonagh and his band of rebels surrendered unconditionally.
In the St. Stephen's Green area, Countess Markievicz and her band
surrendered and were taken to the Castle. These surrenders practically
ended the rebellion in the City of Dublin.
(16) Throughout the night of the 30th April-1st May isolated rebels
continued to snipe the troops, but during the 1st May these were
gradually cleared out, and in conjunction with the police a systematic
house-to-house search for rebels and arms was continued.
(17) During the severe fighting which took place in Dublin the
greatest anxiety was caused by the disquieting reports received
from many
parts of Ireland, and chiefly from—
(a) County Dublin,
(b) County Meath,
(c) County Louth,
(d) County Galway,
(e) County Wexford,
(f) County Clare,
(g) County Kerry.
(18) On the 27th April, as soon as troops became available a detachment
was sent by sea from Kingstown to Arklow to reinforce the garrison
at Kynoch's Explosive Works, and a small party was sent to assist
the R.I.C. post over the wireless station at Skerries. On the
28th April a battalion of the Sherwood Foresters was despatched
by rail to Athlone to protect the artillery and military stores
there and to hold the communication over the River Shannon.
(19) Brigadier-General Stafford, the Garrison Commander at Queenstown,
was directed to use his discretion in the employment of troops
under his command, and on 30th April he was reinforced from England
by one battalion of the 179th Brigade, 60th Division, a battalion
of the Royal Marines, and later by the remainder of the 179th
Brigade.
(20) Brigadier-General Hackett-Pain, who assumed command of the
troops in Ulster, made effective use of the troops under his command,
and it was largely due to the dispositions made by these two Commanders
that the Sinn Feiners in the South and North of Ireland were restrained
from taking a more active part in the rebellion. I received the
greatest assistance from the Inspector-General, Royal Irish Constabulary,
and from all his inspectors and men, and throughout the rebellion
I worked in the closest co-operation with them. In many districts
small posts of these gallant men were isolated and had to defend
themselves, against overwhelming numbers, which they successfully
did except in very few cases. It was with great regret I received
the report on 28th April that a body of Royal Irish Constabulary,
under Inspector Gray, had been ambushed by the rebels at Ashbourne,
which resulted in Inspectors Gray and Smith and eight constables
being killed and 14 wounded. It was not until 30th April that
I was able to spare a mobile column to deal with this body
of rebels, the leaders of which were secured. In other parts of
Ireland similar attacks on police posts had been made by armed
bands of
Sinn Feiners. In order to deal with these, as soon as the Dublin
rebels had been crushed, I organised various mobile columns, each
consisting of from one to two companies of infantry, a squadron
of cavalry, one 18-pounder gun and an armoured car. Each column
was allotted a definite area, which, in close co-operation with
the local police, was gone through, and dangerous Sinn Feiners
and men who were known to have taken an active part in the rising
were arrested; in addition many arms belonging to Sinn Feiners
were surrendered or seized. I am glad to be able to report that
the presence of these columns had the best possible effect on
the people in country districts, in many of which troops had not
been seen for years.
(22) That splendid body of men, the Dublin Metropolitan Police,
could give me little or no assistance, because they were unarmed.
Had they been armed I doubt if the rising in Dublin would have
had the success it did.
(23) I am glad to report that the conduct of the troops was admirable;
their cheerfulness, courage and good discipline, under the most
trying conditions, was excellent. Although doors and windows of
shops and houses had to be broken open, no genuine case of looting
has been reported to me, which I consider reflects the greatest
credit on all ranks.
(24) I wish to acknowledge the great assistance I received from
the Provost of Trinity College; the clergy of all denominations;
civilian medical men; Red Cross nurses, who were untiring in their
attention to the wounded, often rendered under heavy fire; ambulances
provided by Royal Ambulance Corps; the Irish Volunteer Training
Corps and the members of St. John's Ambulance Corps; the Civilian
and Officers Training Corps motor cyclists, who fearlessly carried
despatches through streets infested with snipers; telegraph operators
and engineers; and from the lady operators of the Telephone Exchange,
to whose efforts the only means of rapid communication remained
available. I am glad to be able to record my opinion that the
feelings of the bulk of the citizens of Dublin being against the
Sinn Feiners materially influenced the collapse of the rebellion.
(25) I deplore the serious losses which the troops and the civilian
volunteers have suffered during these very disagreeable operations.
I have the honour to be,
Your most obedient servant,
J. G. MAXWELL.
General.
From the General Officer Commanding-in-Chief, The Forces in Ireland,
to The Secretary of State for War.
Headquarters, Irish Command,
Dublin, 26th May, 1916.
My Lord,
In amplification of the report on the operations undertaken by
the troops in Dublin, which I forwarded to Field-Marshal Lord
French on 25th May, I think it desirable to bring to your notice
the difficult conditions under which the troops had to act.
(1) The rebellion began by Sinn Feiners, presumably acting under
orders, shooting in cold blood certain soldiers and policemen,
simultaneously they took possession of various important buildings
and occupied houses, along the routes into the City of Dublin,
which were likely to be used by troops taking up posts.
(2) Most of the rebels were not in any uniform, and by mixing
with peaceful citizens made it almost impossible for the troops
to distinguish between friend and foe until fire was opened.
(3) In many cases troops having passed along a street seemingly
occupied by harmless people were suddenly fired upon from behind
from windows and roof-tops. Such were the conditions when reinforcements
commenced to arrive in Dublin.
(4) Whilst fighting continued under conditions at once so confused
and so trying, it is possible that some innocent citizens were
shot. It must be remembered that the struggle was in many cases
of a house-to-house character, that sniping was continuous and
very persistent and that it was often extremely difficult to distinguish
between those who were or had been firing upon the troops and
those who had for various reasons chosen to remain on the scene
of the fighting, instead of leaving the houses and passing through
the cordons.
(5) The number of such incidents that has been brought to notice
is very insignificant.
(6) Once the rebellion started the members of the Dublin Metropolitan
Police—an unarmed uniformed force—had to be withdrawn,
or they would have been mercilessly shot down, as, indeed, were
all who had the bad luck to meet the rebels. In their absence
a number of
the worst elements of the city joined the rebels and were armed
by them. The daily record of the Dublin Magistrates' Court proves
that such looting as there was was done by such elements.
(7) There have been numerous incidents of deliberate shooting
on ambulances, and those courageous people who voluntarily came
out to tend to the wounded. The City Fire Brigade, when turned
out in consequence of incendiary fires, were fired on and had
to retire.
(8) As soon as it was ascertained that the rebels had established
themselves in various centres, the first phase of operations was
conducted with a view to isolate them by forming a cordon of troops
round each.
(9) To carry out this streets were selected, along which the cordon
could be drawn. Some of these streets, for instance, North King
Street, were found to be strongly held, rebels occupying the roofs
of houses, upper windows, and strongly constructed barricades.
(10) Artillery fire was only used to reduce the barricades, or
against a particular house known to be strongly held.
(11) The troops suffered severe losses in establishing these cordons,
and, once established, the troops were subjected to a continuous
fire from all directions, especially at night time, and invariably
from persons concealed in houses.
(12) To give an idea of the opposition offered to His Majesty's
troops in the execution of their duty, the following losses occurred:
—
Killed. Wounded.
Officers 17 46
Other ranks ... 89 288
(13) I wish to draw attention to the fact that, when it became
known that the leaders of the rebellion wished to surrender, the
officers used every endeavour to prevent further bloodshed; emissaries
were sent in to the various isolated bands, and time was given
them to consider their position.
(14) I cannot imagine a more difficult situation than that in
which the troops were placed; most of those employed were draft
finding battalions or young Territorials from England, who had
no knowledge of Dublin.
(15) The surrenders, which began on April 30th, were continued
until late on May 1st, during which time there was a considerable
amount of isolated sniping.
(16) Under the circumstances related above, I consider the troops
as a whole behaved with the greatest, restraint, and carried out
their disagreeable and distasteful duties in a manner which reflects
the greatest credit on their discipline.
(17) Allegations on the behaviour of the troops brought to my
notice are being most carefully enquired into. I am glad to say
they are few in number, and these are not all borne out by direct
evidence.
(18) Numerous cases of unarmed persons killed by rebels during
the outbreak have been reported to me. As instances, I may select
the
following for your information: —
J. Brien, a constable of the Dublin Metropolitan Police, was shot
while on duty at Castle Gate, on April 24th. On the same day another
constable of the same force, named M. Lahiff, was shot while on
duty at St. Stephen's Green. On April 25th B. Waters, of Recess,
Monkstown, Co. Dublin, was shot at Mount Street Bridge, while
being driven into Dublin by Captain Scovell, R.A.M.C. All these
were unarmed, as was Captain Scovell. In the last case, the car
was not challenged or asked to stop.
(19) I wish to emphasize that the responsibility for the loss
of life, however it occurred, the destruction of property and
other losses, rests entirely with those who engineered this revolt,
and who, at a time when the Empire is engaged in a gigantic struggle,
invited the assistance and co-operation of the Germans.
I have the honour to be,
My Lord,
Your obedient Servant,
(Sgd.) J. G. MAXWELL,
General.