The
portents were not good. I do not receive too
many books to review, and when I do it is with
great excitement. I unwrap the book carefully,
touch it, feel it, prepare to savour it. Then
I read the press release or other blurb that
comes with it. On this occasion, first impressions
of the book were reduced to nought as I scanned
through the words of the Weidenfeld & Nicolson
PR Department...
Inevitably,
the blurb begins on 1 July 1916: "...60,000
British and Commonwealth soldiers were killed
that day
alone". Weidenfeld
& Nicolson...no they were not! Weidenfeld
& Nicolson...there were no Commonwealth troops
in action on the Somme that day!
It
carries on, summing up the battle: "...leaving
the battlefield strewn with the bodies of over
a
million men". Weidenfeld & Nicolson...no
there were not! Weidenfeld & Nicolson...why
don't you read Peter's book and sack your blurb
writer!
I
don't know Weidenfeld & Nicolson's PR staff.
I am sure they are nice enough young men and
women. But this is just rubbish, and it did
not set me up well to carry on. But I do know
Peter Hart. He's a sensible enough chap. Very
entertaining speaker. Has written some good
books in the past. Is in a privileged position
of access to the records held at the Imperial
War Museum. Let's see.
This is a pretty mighty work,
and by any standards a well produced hardback
volume at over 500 pages including black and
white photos and maps in profusion is extraordinarily
good value at £20 list price.
Peter
has taken on a considerable job: telling the
story of the entire 1916 battle
on the Somme in a single volume, sweeping across
the air war, the artillery war, the relentless
infantry attack and counter attack. I am glad
to say that he does it with pace, balance and
as far as I can see without any significant error
of fact. He is helped by the prolific
use of extracts from the verbal and written records
of men who were there. He is, after all, the
IWM's oral historian, so perhaps this is to be
expected. The words of the soldiers are telling.
Many of their names will be familiar to regular
readers of modern WW1 histories, for their testimonies
are often quoted. Let's choose a few at random...Basil
Farrer, Frank Crozier, Cecil Lewis, Douglas Jerrold,
George Ashurst. Hardly the first time we have
seen their words in print. But to offset that
there are many others less well known and quite
possibly in print for the first time.
For
the reader new to the Somme, this volume will
be a great
overall introduction. The facts are there,
the story clear and tragic. It is perhaps less
likely to appeal to the specialist. Other than
the personal quotes, there will be little new
in the re-telling. But even then it is worth
reading and at the price you can't beat it.
I
have a few nits to pick.
The
selection of photos - beautifully produced,
I must say, is disappointing.
There are thousands of them in the
IWM archive. Why, oh why, do we keep seeing
the same ones?
The
order of battle is useful - but it only lists
the infantry, in a battle where the artillery,
engineers, medics and transport played key
roles.
The
German and French parts of this battle - rather
important - take a distinctly back seat to
a very British view.
On
the other hand, plaudits for the avoidance
of focus on the first hours of the first
day, excellent
maps and good index.
No
question for me. Buy it. And then thank God
you do not have to read the press release.
|