There
can hardly be anyone interested in the 1914-1918
war who has not seen at least one of the handy
Battleground Europe series
of guidebooks, ably edited by Nigel Cave.
For a good many years now they have provided
in a concentrated form a telling of the story
of a given area of the battlefields, advice
for travelling to that area and providing a
number of walking or driving guides to the battlefields
and sites of memorials, cemetries and so on.
I think it is fair to say that while none of
them are bad, the series has suffered from rather
variable quality of work. The best are excellent
models of clarity, full of interest, well illustrated
with good maps and clear touring instructions.
They are also well researched in terms of historical
facts and stories.
Up to now though even the best have always looked
at the battles on the western front through
purely allied - and let's face it, virtually
all British - eyes. Finally, that is all changed.
Jack Sheldon is the author of the recently published
The
German Army on the Somme. His work, delving
into German archives, places him in a super
position to show us the battlefields from the
other side. And what an eye opener it is.
Thiepval and Beaumont Hamel were developed by
the German army into defensive positions of
incredible strength: both resisted the British
attack of 1 July 1916 with comparative ease,
and they only fell into British hands after
dogged effort and the cost of thousands of lives.
Jack helps us understand how these places came
to be such difficult spots to take. He illustrates
both books profusely, with a collection of photographs
and maps that will rarely have been seen outside
Germany before, and probably not much inside
it. He also brings the story alive by using
examples of the stories of a selection of officers,
NCOs and men of the feldgrau. These
works are not only useful guides - they are
enjoyable books to read.
The tours that are suggested also bring a refreshing
and novel aspect to places that are familiar
to many of us.
We
are indebted to Jack Sheldon and those others
who are seeking to put the Somme offensive into
a more balanced context. These
books are great pieces of work and well worth
buying. Next time you go to the Somme, take
time to consider how the mighty German army
turned the rolling gentle farmland into a fortress
and how they fought every bit as bravely in
defence as did their allied counterparts in
attack.
More
book reviews
|
|