This
is a beautifully produced little work, timed
to catch the wave of public interest in the
90th anniversary of the one of the greatest
and most important battles ever fought by the
British. For
anyone with a passing interest, or perhaps
someone generally interested in military history,
it makes a good read. For those with more specialist
interest like myself, I think it is overambitious
and by trying to cover too much ground in a
relatively short work, suffers in consequence.
Martin Pegler was curator at the Royal Armouries
in Leeds, so perhaps it is not surprising that
a considerable chunk of the book is taken up
by technical descriptions of the weapons of
the infantryman - machine guns, rifles and
pistols but not grenades -
of both sides. In places the book is very much
that of the infantry soldier - for example,
the orders of battle that are given describe
all the infantry units but not the artillery,
engineers or other services. The weapons section,
OOB, glossary, bibliography and biographical
notes take up 47
of the 178 pages.
The
remainder is a canter through the strategic
background to the battle and the unfolding
of the battle itself. There are plenty of good
photographs. Those looking for detail of what
the Xth Umpshires did at some trench on a given
day will be disappointed. The scale of the
battle means that it is just not possible to
cover down to that level in a work like this.
But, to his credit, Martin does not dwell on
the famous "First Day" but takes us all through
the months to the mud of the Le Transloy Ridge
and Beaumont Hamel in November 1916, at a summary
level.
If you want detail, you will need the Official
History, or perhaps Chris McCarthy's "The Somme:
the day by day account", not "The attack on
the Somme". If you want a quick overview or
a good gift for someone generally interested,
this would be a good choice.
More
book reviews
|
|